The Stolen Party Argumentative

The characters in the short story, “The Stolen Party” demonstrate striking differences in their values and beliefs. Each character displays unique traits. It is these unique traits, which illustrate different aspects of society. Each character then, represents a portion of the values and beliefs of today’s society.

Rosaura is the main character of this writing. The story revolves around her from start to finish. Rosaura is an inexperienced young girl. This story opens with an argument between Rosaura and her mother. Rosaura wants to go to Luciana’s birthday party. Luciana is in a wealthy family so Rosaura’s mother disapproves of her daughter’s attending the party. In the first few sentences the author makes it evident that Rosaura is financially challenged. Rosaura’s mother says, “I don’t like you going because it is a rich peoples party.” This one sentence already tells me that they are probably not very wealthy. In addition Rosaura is an inexperienced young girl. She is not tarnished by the belief that everyone should be judged according to his or her financial worth.

She, unlike her mother, judges people by who they are and not by how much money they have. When Rosaura’s mother states, “you should not fart higher than your own ass” she shows that she feels below those who are wealthy. Rosaura’s argument shows that she does not feel bound by her financial status. Her financial state isn’t even an issue to her. She says that she wants to go because she is a friend of Luciana and because she was invited. The author also demonstrates Rosaura’s openness in the first few paragraphs of the story. Since Rosaura is only nine years old she has no prior experience of prejudice. She does not realize that her mother might be right about her assumption that not everyone will accept her at the party and treat her with the same respect.

The author begins the story by demonstrating how much Rosaura’s mother loathes the rich. Her disapproval of her daughter’s attending the birthday party, expresses some hidden anger and maybe even jealousy towards those who are wealthy. Rosaura’s mother feels lower than Luceana’s family. She feels that a person’s financial status determines whom a person can associate with. The author eventually reveals that Rosaura’s mother is a maid. Because her job does not pay very high wages she feels inferior to Luciana’s family.

Her feelings of hostility toward the wealthy might come from years of prejudice. Rosaura’s mother constantly feels bound by her financial situation. Rosaura’s mother does not want her daughter going to the party because she is the daughter of humble maid. She feels that her daughter will not be looked upon as an equal, no matter what. Rosaura’s mother states, “That one’s not your friend. You know what you are to them? The maid’s daughter, that’s what.” But no matter how strongly Rosaura’s mother feels about this, she is willing to let her daughter go to the party. This demonstrates the unconditional love she has for her daughter.

There are some characters in this story that are not developed as well as Rosaura and her mother. One of these characters is Luciana. Luciana is very similar to Rosaura in that she sees everyone as an equal. She does not consider Rosaura to be different from any of her other friends. She never considers Rosaura’s financial situation to be important. She treats Rosaura like all of her other friends.

Another character, which is not covered in depth, is Luciana’s cousin. She is brought into this story through an argument with Rosaura. Luciana’s cousin doesn’t know Rosaura but she feels inclined to start an argument with her anyway. Luciana’s cousin begins to question Rosaura. She questions the fact that Rosaura is a friend of Luciana. Luciana’s cousin seems to think that she is better than Rosaura. This shows the reader the first clues that Rosaura’s mother could have been right about wealthy people not accepting Rosaura.

Another character that is only introduced briefly is the magician. The author does not get into his personality or values but it is made clear that he sees all of the children as equal.

The last character that is introduced is Senora Ines. Once again the author does not develop her in depth. The author places her in the story in order to demonstrate the prejudice, which Rosaura’s mother had described. Senora Ines offers Rosaura money at the end of the party rather than a small gift. This demonstrates to Rosaura that she is, in fact, looked upon as being different from the other children.

Each character in this story demonstrates an aspect of society today. Rosaura signifies the unsuspecting poor child. She represents the fact that a person usually does not develop stereotypes until they have experienced many of the aspects of life. Rosaura’s mother is placed in the story to illustrate another fact about today’s society. Rosaura’s mother demonstrates that society influences the way a person thinks. She shows that from years of experience she has developed a pattern of stereotyping wealthy people. Luciana represents the wealthy part of society that does not see less fortunate people as being different. She, like Rosaura, does not stereotype people because of their financial worth. Luciana’s cousin, on the other hand, demonstrates that part of the wealthy population that feels superior to the financially challenged. The magician in this story represents someone like a priest or a charity worker. He sees all of the kids at the party as equals. He is willing to let any of them participate in his magic. Senora Ines plays the part of society that feels obligated to offer charity to those who are less fortunate.

The author not only writes a very interesting story but also provides an important message regarding society. People are too concerned with money in today’s society. If we could all remain innocent (such as Rosaura and Luciana) and never become prejudice towards others the world would be a better place. Everyone would be judged according to who they are and not by what they posses.