We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Review of the 1949 The Third Man film

The whole doc is available only for registered users

A limited time offer! Get a custom sample essay written according to your requirements urgent 3h delivery guaranteed

Order Now

Many faultfinders view The Third Man as the best British post-World War II film noir. There are others (myself included) who trust it to be a standout amongst other ever cases of film noir to leave all of Europe. The Third Man has all the correct fixings: a drawing in, twisty storyline (composed by Graham Greene); a standout amongst the most underhanded and charming lowlifess ever to elegance the screen; fresh, inventive coordinating (by the underrated Carol Reed); a score (by Anton Karas) that it as life-changing as it is eccentric; and cinematography (by Robert Krasker) that uses the highly contrasting medium to its fullest. Not exclusively is The Third Man a sweetheart of the commentators, yet it has been grasped with happiness by the general masses for over five decades.

The verifiable viability of The Third Man is gotten principally from the manner in which the individual parts are mixed together. The film does not depend too vigorously on any single creation angle. It isn’t characterized by its reminiscent photography, or by Karas’ utilization of a zither, by Orson Welles’ scene-taking nearness, or by the on-area utilization of the post-war, besieged out boulevards of Vienna. Rather, these things work to compliment each other. The auteur for this situation is Carol Reed, a movie producer who is infrequently agreed the credit he merits. The Third Man film analysis demonstrated that it is Reed’s most noteworthy triumph, yet it isn’t his just only one. He also created other ones, for example, The Fallen Idol and Oliver! (He won his Oscar for the last mentioned.)

As the years progressed, many savants have pondered whether Orson Welles had an uncredited turn in coordinating The Third Man. As indicated by various sources, Welles and Reed included among them, this was not the situation, and it would do Reed a bad form to recommend anything in actuality. Nonetheless, it is presumably evident that Welles by implication impacted Reed. All things considered, Citizen Kane was seven years of age when The Third Man went into generation, and it is likely that many of the procedures and methodologies spearheaded by Welles in his magnum opus discovered their way into The Third Man, among many other contemporary films.

The essential story is truly clear noir spine chiller like material. There’s a straightforward, hard-drinking saint, a femme fatale, and a reprobate who (actually) remains in the shadows. However, regardless of the standard plotline, the written work of Graham Greene raises things to a larger amount. When he penned The Third Man, Greene knew about the traditions of film noir, and he received them not as platitudes mandated by a classification, but rather as bits of a bigger perplex. Along these lines, the subtext in The
Third Man is more profound and more extravagant than it is in most comparable movies. The distinction is in the points of interest, not in the more extensive brushstrokes.

Joseph Cotten, the determination of maker David O. Selznick (Reed needed James Stewart), is Holly Martins, a moderately gullible American writer who touches base in present war Vienna on take a vocation offered to him by his long-lasting companion, Harry Lime (Orson Welles). At the point when Holly arrives, notwithstanding, he discovers that Harry has as of late passed on in a heartbreaking auto collision. At the burial service, he meets Major Calloway (Trevor Howard), a British individual from the neighborhood military police, who reveals to Holly that he should pivot quickly and go home. Yet, Holly is chomped by the interest bug and stricken by Anna Schmidt (Alida Valli), a puzzling griever at Harry’s memorial service. He supposes there’s more to the account of Harry’s passing than is at first self-evident, and he starts his own particular examination. He soon discovers that there are varying records of what happened that day, and that one of the witnesses – the “third man” to expel Harry’s body from the road – can’t be found. Truth be told, a few of the other witnesses deny his reality. With assistance from Anna and notwithstanding stern resistance from Calloway, Holly pushes on with his examination until the point when he finds that Harry’s passing was a fantasy. The man Holly once called a dear companion is particularly alive, and the driving force of a stunning extortion that has supplanted great penicillin with awful, bringing about far reaching passing and sickness.

The plum part has a place with Welles, who, in spite of being in the film for just 40 minutes, makes a standout amongst the most critical characters in the historical backdrop of film noir. His Harry Lime was so acclaimed, truth be told, that British radio made a progression of radio plays highlighting Lime pre-The Third Man, and procured Welles to by and by fill the role. Welles is given one of the best sections of any film character – abruptly lit up in the obscured niche where he is standing, a cynical, half-taunting appearance all over. Harry is the fallen angel – insidious and flippant (his voracity has brought about death and hopelessness for incalculable youngsters who depended upon the doctored penicillin), yet chipper and charming. His most celebrated words, a short discourse composed by Welles, say a great deal in regards to his character and inspirations:

“In Italy for a long time under the Borgias they had fighting, dread, murder, and carnage, yet they created Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, and the Renaissance. In Switzerland they had brotherly love – they had 500 long periods of popular government and peace, and what did that create? The cuckoo clock.”

Welles’ most vital commitment to film might be Citizen Kane, however an expansive section of the motion picture going populace will recall him as Harry Lime.

In spite of being charged above Welles, Joseph Cotten is regularly the overlooked man in The Third Man, yet the film wouldn’t have been the same without him. Reed may have needed Stewart, however it’s difficult to contend with the activity turned in by Cotten, who offers an advising picture of somebody understanding selling out – the two his own particular and his best friend’s. The hidden explanations for the double-crossings don’t much make a difference (Harry carried out his out of insatiability, while Holly’s is persuaded by the craving to get a criminal off the roads), and both have results. Holly starts the film as a blameless – an essayist of Zane Gray-style Westerns who is in Vienna on a warbler. After the occasions of The Third Man, he has taken in various hard exercises about companionship, unwaveringness, and equity.

The film’s adoration intrigue/femme fatale is played by Italian performer Alida Valli (charged amid the first discharge as “Valli”), who brings both a hard edge and a gentler weakness to the part. In the same way as other ladies in film noir, she is the question of solitary love, and, monitoring the hero’s enthusiasm for her, she manipulates his warmth. This Ingrid Bergman-like performance spoke to the high purpose of Valli’s vocation as an on-screen character in English-dialect films. Be that as it may, while her star never rose in Hollywood, she has in excess of 100 Italian credits on her resume (counting two stretches under incredible frightfulness executive Dario Argento). English performer Trevor Howard, close to the start of a long and prosperous profession, is Major Calloway. Ernst Deutsch is the altogether offensive Baron Kurtz (whose appearance recommends “weasel” and “rodent”). Also, in a littler part, Bernard Lee plays Sergeant Paine, Calloway’s correct hand man. Lee is most likely best known as “M”, James Bond’s manager – a part he attempted from the beginning of the arrangement until the point that weakness made him resign after Moonraker (that is 11 appearances).

From a visual point of view, The Third Man reliably awes. The highly contrasting cinematography is fresh and clean. Orson Welles is credited as once saying that each performance is better in highly contrasting, and, seeing something like The Third Man, it’s not hard to comprehend why. The climate is more profound and the pictures are all the more striking. This is particularly valid for the settings crosswise over Vienna, and beneath the lanes in the sewers, where the last pursue and encounter come to pass (in spite of the fact that a British sound stage was raised to twofold for this area when Welles declined to film in the real sewers). Reed and his cinematographer use various odd plots for their shots, and play with shadows in intriguing ways. Who can overlook the presence of an inflatable dealer, whose shadow towers high finished the ignorant boulevards? That is one of many pictures that waits.

Anton Karas’ score for the film, played on a zither, is one of The Third Man’s best developments. Rather than depending on the standard dismal, irritable symphonic music that was normal for noir tries, Reed chose to bet by navigating an alternate highway (one contradicted by Selznick). Be that as it may, Karas’ particular themes work so well when marry to The Third Man’s visuals that it’s relatively difficult to imagine the film assembled in an unexpected way. There’s something cheerful yet despairing about the sound of the zither that catches the disposition in a way that a conventional course of action would have been not able do.

It would be neglectful on the off chance that I didn’t say the film’s consummation. It’s a long, whole shot of Holly remaining by the side of the street, sitting tight for Anna. Without even a look toward him, she comes closer from a separation, passes him, and proceeds towards the camera until the point when she leaves outline. The camera waits on Holly as he illuminates a cigarette and clearly understands that he isn’t, all things considered, going to get the young lady. It’s the ideal method to close the film, and is all the more essential due to the manner in which it was shot. Both Selznick and creator Graham Greene had at first contended for something more cheery (Holly and Anna strolling off affectionately intertwined), yet Reed oppose this idea. He felt this was the correct method to end things, and, luckily, his understanding was triumphant.

For admirers of film noir, The Third Man is obviously an unquestionable requirement see – one of the perfect works of art of a classification that has contained everything from point of reference movies to low-spending potboilers. Due in vast part to the carefulness of those included, the motion picture is for all intents and purposes without defect.

It’s a champion from a period in which there were many awesome movies, and an outline for endless inferior copycat spine chillers to come a short time later. The Third Manmanages the praiseworthy accomplishment of joining well known diversion with imaginative accomplishment, making it a drawing in and convincing survey involvement for almost any potential group of onlookers part, paying little heed to his or her experience and standpoint.


  • The Third Man review – a near-perfect work | Film
  • The Third Man (1949) – Full Cast & Crew – IMDb
  • The Criterion Collection – The Third Man(1949)

Read next:

Martin Scorsese’s The Departed Movie Analysis
Monty Python and the Holy Grail – a Brilliant 1975 Film
Chaplin’s Modern Times Analysis

Related Topics

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay
Materials Daily
100,000+ Subjects
2000+ Topics
Free Plagiarism
All Materials
are Cataloged Well

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
Sorry, but only registered users have full access

How about getting this access

Your Answer Is Very Helpful For Us
Thank You A Lot!


Emma Taylor


Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?

Can't find What you were Looking for?

Get access to our huge, continuously updated knowledge base

The next update will be in:
14 : 59 : 59