We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Compare and Contrast Two Nursing Theories

The whole doc is available only for registered users

A limited time offer! Get a custom sample essay written according to your requirements urgent 3h delivery guaranteed

Order Now

Nursing requires daily, hourly and even up to the minute tasks and details. The nurse is reactive and supportive, caring and efficient. It may be overwhelming to keep up with the many activities of daily nursing. But being professional nurse is all that and more. It means that you have an internal roadmap to patient care, a guide that helps you achieve good outcomes. This is where nursing theory comes in. Nursing theory can help you with overt and covert problems, as well as inform your nursing decisions. In the two studies that I read, each used a very different theory to guide their nursing care. That is because nursing is so diverse, and we are fortunate to have had many beacons of light come before us in the form of Grand Theorists. I chose to contrast the Nicely article (2011), using Virginia Henderson’s theory, with the Merrit article(2010), using Hildegard Peplau’s theory.

Virginia Henderson‚Äôs theory centers around immediate care of the physical needs of the patient and family, emphasizing deep caring. Nicely‚Äôs article organizes patient care for the brain-dead patient according to Henderson‚Äôs 14 nursing support activities that were intended to create independence for the ill patient. Nicely argues that these activities are also appropriate for the brain-dead patient for important reasons. The brain-dead patient should be treated with the same care as if the patient were to live, because the patient‚Äôs organs will indeed live on and be harvested if the patient is treated correctly. Correctly, according to Henderson‚Äôs theory is to support 14 activities, some of which are ‚Äúeating and drinking‚ÄĚ, ‚Äúelimination of body waste‚ÄĚ, ‚Äúselect suitable dress and undress‚ÄĚ and ‚Äúdesirable posture, sleep and rest‚ÄĚ, to name a few.

It seems implausible to imagine that Henderson had anything in mind other than the ‚Äúlive‚ÄĚ patient when she penned her theory, and the interesting twist here is the use of this theory for the patient who has expired. The theory is practical and immediately applicable, making it a good choice for the acute situation of recent brain-death. Brain death and subsequent organ harvesting benefit from a clear road map that has very little deviations and is universally applicable. But the care of the patient who presents with mental health needs requires a theory that encompasses long-term care. We have come to learn that mental health does not have a one-size-fits-all quick solution. Hildegard Peplau argues that the patient will benefit most when the nurse takes on specific roles to model for the patient.

Peplau¬†emphasizes ‚Äúthe person rather than the problem‚ÄĚ, and focuses on the ‚Äúshared humanity‚ÄĚ between patient and nurse. In Merrit‚Äôs case study, the nurse adopts the seven roles proposed by Peplau, some of which are ‚ÄúThe stranger role‚ÄĚ, ‚ÄúThe resource role‚ÄĚ, ‚ÄúThe teaching role‚ÄĚ, and others. These roles are carefully delineated, so as to provide an education for all nurses on the ‚Äúinterpersonal relations‚ÄĚ between patient and nurse. In Merrit‚Äôs case study, these interpersonal relations form the basis for healing, which takes place over an extended period of time.

Peplau’s theory guides the authors of the study to gain patient trust, provide counsel, educate, refer and heal. The theory allows for this to happen over time. The nature of mental health requires self -inquiry for both patient and nurse, and time for self-reflection. Henderson’s model would not be adequate for this type of nursing. The science of nursing is fortunate to have various theories to draw from for diverse nursing situations.


Nicely, B., & DeLario, G. T. (2011). Virginia Henderson’s principles and practiceof nursing applied to organ donation after brain death. Progress in Transplantation, 21(1), 72-77. (Links to an external site.)

Merritt, M. K., & Procter, N. (2010). Conceptualising the functional role of mental health consultation‚Äďliaison nurse in multi-morbidity,using Peplau‚Äôs nursing theory. Contemporary Nurse 34(2), 158‚Äď166. (Links to an external site.)

Related Topics

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay
Materials Daily
100,000+ Subjects
2000+ Topics
Free Plagiarism
All Materials
are Cataloged Well

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
Sorry, but only registered users have full access

How about getting this access

Your Answer Is Very Helpful For Us
Thank You A Lot!


Emma Taylor


Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?

Can't find What you were Looking for?

Get access to our huge, continuously updated knowledge base

The next update will be in:
14 : 59 : 59